Reds FeedChase Petty
P · Age 23 · Bats Right · Throws Right
Where things stand
Chase Petty graduated to MLB eligibility after the Reds promoted him from their minor league system, but he has struggled at the big league level, contributing to Cincinnati's farm system receiving the lowest grade in baseball for 2026. Analysts view Petty as better suited for back-of-the-rotation innings rather than as a reliable mid-rotation starter, and the organization has raised questions about his ability to develop into a consistent starting pitcher.
Synthesized by MLB Feed Network from the 6 stories below. How we write these
2026 season
Stats from the MLB Stats API.
Contract
See the full Reds payroll.
Chase Petty coverage
Reds farm system gets the lowest grade in baseball for 2026
Baseball America assigned the Cincinnati Reds farm system a D grade for 2026, the lowest mark given to any team alongside the San Diego Padres and Philadelphia Phillies. The Reds' prospect pool deteriorated significantly after several players graduated to the majors, including Chase Burns, Sal Stewart, Rhett Lowder, Edwin Arroyo, and Chase Petty, with most struggling at the big league level. Alfredo Duno and Carter Graham stand out as bright spots, but the system lacks depth in pitching and has few proven prospects in Double-A and Triple-A, leaving the organization years away from meaningful contributions to a struggling major league team.
Redleg NationReds' farm system raises a huge red flag for the 2027 season
Cincinnati's farm system ranking dropped from 12th to 23rd between the preseason and August, partly because prospects like Sal Stewart and Edwin Arroyo graduated to the majors. The more significant concern is the system's composition: four of the top 10 prospects are shortstops, and nine of the top 10 are position players, leaving only 19-year-old Aaron Watson as a promising pitching prospect. With Hunter Greene out for all of 2027 following his second Tommy John surgery and Brady Singer becoming a free agent, the Reds lack depth behind ace Chase Burns and will struggle to fill rotation spots beyond their top three starters. Prospects like Rhett Lowder, Chase Petty, and Julian Aguiar carry question marks and are better suited as back-of-the-rotation options rather than reliable No. 4 or 5 starters.
Blog Red MachineIs the Cincinnati Reds farm system underrated?
ESPN's Kiley McDaniel ranked the Cincinnati Reds farm system 21st overall, which is higher than recent assessments but still reflects significant decline. The system lost five prospects to MLB eligibility in the past year—Chase Burns, Sal Stewart, Rhett Lowder, Edwin Arroyo, and Chase Petty—while remaining prospects have largely stalled or regressed, with only catcher Alfredo Duno ranking in the top 100 prospects. The organization has minimal depth at Double-A and Triple-A, with most promising talent concentrated in lower minor league levels, and the pitching prospects present serious questions about their ability to develop into starting pitchers. Whether the farm system is underrated depends on how much weight is given to lower-level prospects with upside versus the shallow upper-level depth that typically matters more for organizational development.
Redleg NationIs the Cincinnati Reds farm system underrated?
ESPN's Kiley McDaniel ranked the Cincinnati Reds farm system 21st overall, higher than recent assessments but still reflecting significant decline. The system lost five prospects to MLB eligibility in the past year—Chase Burns, Sal Stewart, Rhett Lowder, Edwin Arroyo, and Chase Petty—while remaining prospects have stalled or regressed, with only catcher Alfredo Duno appearing in McDaniel's Top 100. The organization has minimal depth at Double-A and Triple-A levels, with most promising talent concentrated in lower minor league levels, creating uncertainty about whether the farm system is underrated or overrated depending on how much weight is given to prospects far from the majors.
Redleg NationTerry Francona’s veteran loyalty could derail the Reds’ young talent
Manager Terry Francona's strength in supporting his players can become a liability when he retains struggling veterans too long, potentially hindering the Reds' development of young talent. With Cincinnati's 2024 season effectively over after beginning with playoff aspirations, the team should use remaining games to give prospects like Hector Rodriguez, Noelvi Marte, and Carlos Jorge playing time instead of keeping veterans like TJ Friedl, who is batting .164, in the lineup. The article suggests the Reds should also prioritize younger pitchers like Luis Mey and Chase Petty over established bullpen arms like Pierce Johnson to evaluate their potential for 2027 and beyond.
Blog Red Machine7 Reds players who could earn September call-ups following Michael Toglia's arrival
The Cincinnati Reds promoted Michael Toglia from Triple-A Louisville to the active roster after he hit 22 home runs in the minor leagues. With roster expansion to 28 players coming September 1, the Reds have several candidates for call-ups, including pitcher Zach Maxwell, who has struggled with command, and infielder Edwin Arroyo, who hit .244 in 44 games earlier this season. Other potential September additions include catcher Will Banfield, pitcher Chase Petty, and infielder Michael Chavis, who has posted a .249 average with 21 home runs in 92 Triple-A games.
Blog Red Machine